Atmanspacher’s Dual-Aspect Monism
Monism › Dual-Aspect Monism
Mind and Matter as Aspects of Neutral Reality
This theory posits that mind (mental domain) and matter (material domain) are inseparable manifestations, or aspects, of a single underlying, fundamental, psychophysically neutral reality. The mental and physical domains emerge dynamically by breaking the holistic symmetry of this fundamental reality, leading to mutual correlations between them.
What consciousness is
Consciousness (the mental domain) is identified as one of two irreducible aspects emerging from an underlying, non-material, psychophysically neutral domain, which is the singular fundamental reality.
Mind and body
Mind and matter are inseparable aspects of the underlying neutral reality and are jointly caused by it. They manifest mutual correlations (like synchronicity) that reflect the lost holism of the underlying domain (decompositional view).
Mechanism
Decompositional emergence achieved by breaking the holistic symmetry of the psychophysically neutral domain. Acausal correlations (synchronicity) are the key phenomenon linking the mental and physical aspects.
Core claims
- Mind and matter are inseparable, distinct aspects/manifestations of a single, underlying psychophysically neutral reality.
- The mental and physical emerge by breaking the holistic symmetry of the underlying domain (decompositional view).
- Mental and material manifestations inherit mutual correlations (synchronicity/entanglement) because they are jointly caused by the neutral level.
Criticisms
The decompositional dual-aspect approach is based on speculations derived from quantum holism that clearly exceed the scope of contemporary quantum theory. It can be criticized as abstract and philosophical rather than empirically grounded.
Implications
- AI consciousness: Uncertain
- Consciousness depends on emergence from the holistic psychophysically neutral domain via specific symmetry breaking. It is unclear whether artificial systems could replicate the non-computational ontological conditions necessary to tap into this underlying reality.
- Survival beyond death: Possible
- Since the underlying reality (neutral domain) is fundamental and permanent, and consciousness emerges from it, aspects of consciousness may persist, particularly given the theory's linkage to the collective unconscious.
- Meaning and purpose: Cosmic/Ultimate
- The theory explicitly aims to reconstruct the deep structure of meaning as a fundamental feature of reality, linking acausal correlations (synchronicity) to qualitative meaning.
- Virtual immortality: Uncertain
- Virtual immortality via duplication relies on functionalism. Since consciousness is rooted in the dynamic, holistic emergence from the psychophysically neutral level, mere computational duplication of physical states would likely be insufficient to preserve the mental aspect.
Related theories
- Bohm's Implicate-Explicate Order (Influence/Compatible)
- Jung's Collective Unconscious and Synchronicity (Influence/Compatible)
- Russellian Monism (Contrast/Distinction)
- Whitehead's Process Theory (Contrast/Distinction)
Sources
- Quantum Approaches to Consciousness (2020)
- The Pauli–Jung conjecture and its relatives: a formally augmented outline (2020)
- Dual-Aspect Monism and the Deep Structure of Meaning (2022)
Explore all theories on the Consciousness Atlas · Compare Atmanspacher’s Dual-Aspect Monism with other theories · Which theory of consciousness fits you?