Abstract Realism (AR)
Non-Reductive › Abstract Realism
‘Consciousness as Complementarity of Perspectives’
Abstract Realism proposes a complementarity between the first-person (experiencer) and third-person (observed) perspectives, each containing an equivalent observer function, to bridge the mind-matter explanatory gap . Consciousness is generated in the brain by the bi-directional causal interaction of two information systems, realized as electromagnetic fields, where one serves as the observing reference for the other .
What consciousness is
Consciousness is the resulting state of a causal, bi-directional interaction between two information systems (two electromagnetic fields) in the brain, configured so that one is the observing reference for the other .
Mind and body
Consciousness is causally powerful and is produced by physical systems (the brain) when organized in a sufficiently complex manner . Mind and matter are viewed as a complementarity of first- and third-person perspectives, integrating consciousness with physics .
Mechanism
The phenomenal simultaneity between experiencer and experienced , achieved via the bi-directional causal interaction of two electromagnetic fields .
Core claims
- The theory solves the mind-matter problem by using complementarity of first- and third-person perspectives .
- Consciousness arises from the bi-directional causal interaction of two electromagnetic fields acting as observing references .
- The causal mechanics are unobservable in principle, making consciousness indistinguishable from strong emergence .
Criticisms
The theory relies on causal mechanics that are unobservable in principle , which limits empirical verification. It draws on electromagnetic field theories, which are themselves diverse (9.3) .
Implications
- AI consciousness: Likely
- The theory states that consciousness can be produced by physical systems, 'even synthetic ones,' provided they achieve the necessary bi-directional, causal complexity (i.e., the interaction of the two information systems/EM fields) .
- Survival beyond death: Unlikely
- As a Non-Reductive Physicalist theory, consciousness is tied to complex physical mechanisms (EM fields in the brain) . While phenomenal presence creates the logical possibility of a disembodied mind, the central mechanism is dependent on the brain's physical operation .
- Meaning and purpose: Uncertain
- The focus of the theory is on solving the mind-matter explanatory gap. Non-Reductive Physicalism generally sits in the middle ground regarding ultimate meaning/purpose, making it possible but not explicitly entailed by the theory itself .
- Virtual immortality: Likely
- If consciousness is generated by physical systems with proven causal power, then the advanced technology required to duplicate these complex informational and field dynamics in a virtual substrate should allow for the uploading of the mental self, consistent with the non-reductive physicalist categorization .
Related theories
- Conscious Electromagnetic Information Theory (CEMI) (Overlap (incorporates the mechanism of two electromagnetic fields))
- Emergence (Compatible (consciousness is deemed indistinguishable from strong emergence))
- Materialism (Critique (AR explicitly avoids appealing to reductive physicalism))
- Dualism and Idealism (Critique (AR seeks integration within physics without appealing to dualism or idealism))
Sources
- Simultaneity of consciousness with physical reality: the key that unlocks the mind-matter problem, John Sanfey (2023)
Explore all theories on the Consciousness Atlas · Compare Abstract Realism (AR) with other theories · Which theory of consciousness fits you?