Integrated Information Theory (IIT)
Integrated Info
An experience is identical to a conceptual structure that is maximally irreducible intrinsically.
IIT is an original, radical model that proposes a definition for conscious experience and specifies which physical systems can possess it, starting from the phenomenology of consciousness (axioms). It translates these axioms into physical postulates based on intrinsic cause-effect power, featuring a mathematical measure Φ(Phi) to quantify a system's capacity for informational integration, which correlates with the degree of consciousness.
What consciousness is
Consciousness is identified as a Φ-structure, a maximally reduced conceptual structure existing in 'qualia space'. An experience is identical to this conceptual structure, meaning its phenomenal properties correspond precisely to the physical properties of the cause-effect structure unfolded from the physical substrate of consciousness (PSC).
Mind and body
IIT asserts an explanatory identity: an experience is identical to a Φ-structure. It contends that the conscious entity is the Φ-structure expressing its causal powers, not the neural substrate itself. This framework leaves no room for emergence or dualism.
Mechanism
The core principle is Integrated Information (Φ(Phi)), which quantifies the system's irreducibility. The Exclusion Postulate ensures that only the maximally irreducible cause-effect structure (the Φ-structure) exists intrinsically, defining the boundaries and grain of consciousness.
Core claims
- Consciousness is quantified by integrated information (Φ(Phi)); digital computers have negligible Φ(Phi).
- An experience is identical to a maximally irreducible intrinsic conceptual structure (Φ-structure).
- True free will is a corollary, grounded in the intrinsic powers of the conscious entity.
- Preliminary brain scanning data calculating Φ(Phi) for neural networks, such as during anesthesia, seem to correlate with states of consciousness.
Criticisms
The theory faces criticism for anti-common sense predictions (imputing consciousness to simple objects). A public letter characterized IIT as 'pseudoscience'. Critics challenge that experiments test only idiosyncratic predictions and not the core metaphysical ideas. Chalmers noted the 'pseudoscience' label was disproportionate and caused vast collateral damage.
Implications
- AI consciousness: No
- Koch, a proponent, argues that consciousness is not computable. Digital computers have negligible integrated information (Φ(Phi)) due to hardware structure, meaning they can never be sentient, regardless of intelligence.
- Survival beyond death: Uncertain
- If phenomenal consciousness requires a radically new structure (like IIT's postulates), the potential permanence of these 'inscrutable things' cannot be rejected, leaving the possibility of survival open, even though IIT does not explicitly espouse life after death.
- Meaning and purpose: Uncertain
- While the measurement and analysis of consciousness do not convey ultimate meaning, the speculative nature and novelty of the innumerable nth dimensional conceptual structures (conscious percepts) warrants suspending judgment on ultimate meaning/purpose/value.
- Virtual immortality: No
- If consciousness is a fundamental property tied to real cause-effect power, a digital simulation (uploading) would only create a 'perfect zombie'—an entity that acts like the original but lacks subjective consciousness—because the simulation is virtual, lacking the required real cause-effect power.
Related theories
- Baars's and Dehaene's Global Workspace Theory (Critique (IIT disagrees radically with the functionalist approach of GWT, and advocates criticized adversarial collaborations testing GWT against IIT.))
- Panpsychism (Shared intuitions/Distancing (IIT shares the intuition that consciousness is fundamental and graded, but claims to specify which systems are conscious, partially solving the combination problem, a major shortcoming of panpsychism.))
- Tegmark's State of Matter (Extension (Tegmark’s approach generalizes IIT for neural-network-based consciousness and arbitrary quantum systems.))
- Qualia Research Institute’s State-Space (Compatible/Influence (QRI leverages the mathematical isomorphism concept from IIT and is most compatible with it.))
Sources
- From the phenomenology to the mechanisms of consciousness: integrated information theory 3.0, Oizumi, Albantakis, Tononi (2014)
- Consciousness: here, there and everywhere?, Tononi and Koch (2015)
- Only what exists can cause: an intrinsic powers view of free will, Tononi et al. (2022)
- Then I Am Myself the World: What Consciousness Is and How to Expand It, Koch (2024)
Explore all theories on the Consciousness Atlas · Compare Integrated Information Theory (IIT) with other theories · Which theory of consciousness fits you?