Rovelli’s Relational Physics
Quantum › Relationship Physics
‘Consciousness as Perspectival Reality’
This theory takes a deflationary view of the hard problem by positing that consciousness is sufficiently accounted for by the profoundly relational aspect of physics, especially quantum mechanics and general relativity. Physics, when properly understood as perspectival—describing how entities manifest themselves to one another—dissolves the perceived mismatch between the physical world and subjective experience.
What consciousness is
Consciousness, or 'thoughts', is accounted for by the perspective-dependent, relational manifestations of interacting physical systems, which is sufficient within the description provided by modern physics.
Mind and body
Deflationary Identity/Sufficiency. When reality is described as a web of interacting systems, the discrepancy between the mental and the physical seems much less dramatic, suggesting a deep co-relation where physics is sufficient to account for thoughts.
Mechanism
The principle that physics is fundamentally relational (how entities manifest themselves to one another) provides the organizational principle necessary to account for conscious phenomena like thoughts.
Core claims
- The perceived discrepancy between the mental and physical is lessened when reality is understood in terms of interacting, relational systems.
- Physical reality is inherently perspectival, always described relative to a physical system, which mirrors subjective experience.
- Physics, understood relationally, is sufficient to account for complex phenomena like thoughts and thunderstorms.
Criticisms
Critics note that even if physics is relational, subjective experience does not necessarily seem relational, and this view may fail to account fully for the subjective and qualitative aspects of consciousness.
Implications
- AI consciousness: Likely
- If consciousness (thoughts) is fully accounted for by the interaction of complex physical systems described relationally, then any sufficiently complex artificial system whose operation is governed by these physical laws would achieve consciousness.
- Survival beyond death: No
- The theory explicitly rejects consciousness playing a special, intimate role in quantum mechanics and accounts for thoughts via complex physical systems. Therefore, consciousness is tied to the existence of the physical system (e.g., the brain), which dissolves upon death.
- Meaning and purpose: Humanistic only
- The focus is on describing how reality is structured through relations. While complex emergent systems (humans) can create meaning, the fundamental physical reality described by relational physics provides no cosmic teleology or ultimate purpose.
- Virtual immortality: Likely
- Since consciousness is accounted for by the structure and interaction of physical systems, the precise duplication or simulation of these complex relational physical states in an artificial substrate should achieve virtual immortality, provided the technology is sufficiently advanced.
Related theories
- Panpsychism (Compatible (Supports a 'very mild form'))
- Stapp's Collapsing the Wave Function via Asking "Questions" (Critique (Rovelli argues against consciousness having a special role in quantum mechanics' collapse.))
- Musser's "Is It Really So Hard?" (Influence (Musser approvingly quotes Rovelli’s relational approach.))
Sources
- Relations and panpsychism, C. Rovelli (2021)
- Consciousness is irrelevant to quantum mechanics - an interview with Carlo Rovelli, C. Rovelli (2022)
- Rovelli’s relational quantum mechanics, monism and quantum becoming, M. Dorato (2016)
Explore all theories on the Consciousness Atlas · Compare Rovelli’s Relational Physics with other theories · Which theory of consciousness fits you?