Schooler’s Resonance Theory and Subjective Time
Anomalous › Resonance Theory and Subjective Time
‘Consciousness via Nested Resonance and Subjective Time’
This theory combines two novel ideas: a resonance mechanism, where consciousness arises from the interaction of multiple levels or streams of awareness, and the hypothesis that conscious experience is linked to an observer's movement through objective time relative to an unacknowledged dimension of subjective time. This framework is motivated by research into meta-consciousness and anomalous cognition.
What consciousness is
Consciousness is identified as the changing informational states associated with an observer’s movement through objective time relative to a subjective dimension of time. It is structured by multiple interacting levels of awareness connected via resonance.
Mind and body
Consciousness interfaces with the physical brain via resonance mechanisms. The mind, through its connection to subjective time, has unexplained aspects that transcend standard physicalist constraints, possibly supporting anomalous cognition.
Mechanism
Shared resonance (including cross-frequency coupling) enabling instantaneous communication and integration across multiple levels of consciousness, combined with the presence of a subjective dimension of time.
Core claims
- Consciousness is structured by multiple, nested levels of awareness forming a 'Cartesian Multiplex'.
- The subjective experience of unity and richness arises from shared resonance leading to phase transitions in information flow.
- Anomalous cognition, such as precognition, implies a link between consciousness and an objective, yet currently unrecognized, subjective dimension of time.
Criticisms
The theory faces strong skepticism for its inclusion of anomalous cognition and its endorsement of a 'Cartesian Theater' (Multiplex), which conflicts with strong deflationary models. Psi claims often suffer from replication failures.
Implications
- AI consciousness: Uncertain
- As an Anomalous and Altered States Theory, AI consciousness is possible if artificial systems reach a complexity level sufficient to 'automatically' tap into the non-material 'grid' or access the subjective dimension of time required for the theory's specific mechanisms.
- Survival beyond death: Yes
- This theory belongs to a category (AAST) which supports an expanded reality and often gives credence to some form of existence or state of consciousness after biological death, supported by its reliance on non-physical temporal aspects.
- Meaning and purpose: Uncertain
- By positing an expanded reality and a subjective temporal dimension related to consciousness, the theory suggests potential for new kinds or levels of ultimate meaning and purpose beyond reductive accounts.
- Virtual immortality: Not needed
- If consciousness is fundamentally non-local or tied to a subjective temporal dimension that persists after bodily death (supporting survival), digital uploading or simulation is either unnecessary or insufficient to capture the core 'self'.
Related theories
- Panpsychism (Compatible/Extension)
- Dennett's Multiple Drafts Model (Critique)
- Integrated Information Theory (Compatible)
Sources
- The easy part of the hard problem: a resonance theory of consciousness, T. Hunt and J. Schooler (2019)
- Bridging the objective/subjective divide: towards a metaperspective of science and experience, J. Schooler (2014)
- Entertaining without endorsing: the case for the scientific investigation of anomalous cognition, J. Schooler, S. Baumgart, M. Franklin (2018)
Explore all theories on the Consciousness Atlas · Compare Schooler’s Resonance Theory and Subjective Time with other theories · Which theory of consciousness fits you?