Open the map

Big question

Does consciousness give life meaning or purpose?

What a theory says consciousness is shapes what it can say about meaning. If experience is a late product of evolution in a universe without goals, purpose comes from people and their projects. If consciousness is fundamental, or belongs to a soul whose origin lies beyond the body, purpose may be part of how reality is made.

Materialist theories almost all answer ‘Humanistic only’. Owen Flanagan’s ‘The Really Hard Problem: Meaning in a Material World’ (2007) makes a sustained case for finding meaning without cosmic backing, and functionalists and identity theorists generally leave purpose to human values. Phenomenological theories more often agree than not, grounding meaning in lived experience.

Idealist, dualist and anomalous theories mostly answer ‘Cosmic or ultimate’. If mind is the ground of reality, or a soul has a destiny beyond death, meaning does not rest on human choice alone. Several quantum theories join them, such as Roger Penrose and Stuart Hameroff’s Orch OR, which ties moments of experience to the fine structure of spacetime. Panpsychist theories more often land on ‘Uncertain’, since experience everywhere does not by itself give the universe a goal, though Philip Goff argues in ‘Why? The Purpose of the Universe’ (2023) that it has one.

The list below groups every theory under ‘Cosmic or ultimate’, ‘Humanistic only’ or ‘Uncertain’, each with a one-line reason drawn from the theory itself. A ‘Humanistic only’ answer locates meaning in what conscious beings value and do, with no source beyond them.

How the theories answer

83 theories don't take a position on this question.

Cosmic or ultimate 121

Highlight these on the map →

Humanistic only 196

Highlight these on the map →

Uncertain 57

Highlight these on the map →

No position (83)

Other big questions